Because some, or I should say MANY Americans and alot of them right here in Blogland, are saying Obamas response to the oil gusher disaster has been SLOW, I went Googling for some info and found this interesting and truthful piece here.
Former Secretary of State Colin Powell minced no words in a talk with ABC News. Powell said President Obama should muscle BP aside and move in with “decisive force.” The general had one thing in mind, and that’s a military response and seizure of the operation. Powell thinks and talks like a hard-nosed military man. So his demand for a military solution to the BP spill is understandable. Powell didn’t say how the government, let alone the military, could cap the runaway well and insure that it stay capped. But Powell and the wave of media pundits, politicians, and much of the public still shout at Obama to impose a total government takeover of the operation. The shout is futile and wrongheaded. The Obama critics shout it at him in part to beat up on him, and in part out of ignorance at what the government can do.
When a hazardous substance poses a major threat to the health and well-being of U.S. citizens, the president can invoke provisions of the Clean Water Act and the Oil Pollution Act to take full charge. But the BP spill is in international waters and technically federal law doesn’t apply to that. Even if the government makes the compelling legal case that the BP spill poses a grave enough threat for government agencies or the military to step in, then what? Every credible military expert who’s weighed in on what the military can do if it were called on to take over the cap and control of an errant offshore drill operation has said that it would be totally lost. Its deep sea technical capability and undersea imager technology is too limited, and untested in this kind of complex operation. The bitter pill that the public must swallow – according to every scientist, engineer, and technician who’s weighed in on the spill -- is that BP created the problem, and despite its flop so far in fixing it, it has the technology and expertise to do the job. The military and government agencies can take over containment, cleanup and construction. BUT THE GOVERNMENT HAS DISPATCHED MORE THAN 20,000 RESPONDERS, DOZENS OF SHIPS, AND FLOATING OPERATION STATIONS THAT ARE DOING THOSE FUNCTIONS.
Government agencies can bar any company that engages in fraudulent, reckless or criminal conduct from doing business with the government. Given BP’s dismissal of safety rules, costing dozens of lives and maiming and injuring many others, the pile of lawsuits against it, and the lies its officials have told regulators and investigators about its operations, a solid case could be made that the government can and should bar BP from government business.
But there are problems with this. BP is the largest oil and gas producer in the Gulf of Mexico and operates some 22,000 oil and gas wells across the country. It is a top supplier of fuel to the military, and employs thousands. The disbarment process would take at least a year, and either BP, the military, or -- incredible as it sounds -- another government agency can claim in court that disbarment would pose a monumental national security risk to the country. This is not academic speculation. In the past when BP came under fire for legal and environmental malfeasance, these concerns were raised, and the talk of disbarment quickly fizzled.
Then there’s the clamor for indictments and jail. Attorney General Eric Holder says he’ll look seriously at criminal charges against BP.
But it would take months, even years, to build a case that BP executives willfully intended to commit the violations. That’s a nearly insurmountable legal bar. The best that can be hoped for are hefty civil penalties, fines and settlements. That’s been the case in the past with Exxon and BP, and the oil giants didn’t miss a beat. They were back to business as usual.
The BP spill is not solely about what Obama can or should do. The catastrophe is a political grenade that Sarah Palin, the GOP, Tea Party activists, and the pack of rightwing talk jocks have eagerly tossed at Obama to tar him as a weak, ineffectual leader and grab more seats from the Democrats in the November elections. When the first drop oozed out of the well, if Obama had declared a national security emergency, sent in the troops, and clamped the cuffs on BP CEO's, the Obama bashers would have screamed dictator, heavy-handed government interference, and socialist takeover. When that didn't happen, they dredged up the phony comparison to Bush's Katrina bungle and reamed him for being cautious, vacillating, and sending out mixed signals.
The BP spill is the perfect storm of political one-upmanship and environmental catastrophe. This insures that the shout for Obama to do what he can’t do with BP – that is, muscle BP aside -- will get even louder.
Ain't that just the friggin truth!!!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
20 comments:
The rightwing has shown all along that they will oppose anything that Obama does. The gusher is just another example. It is always politics first with the republicans.
Offhand, I can't think of anything that Obama has done that the republicans have agreed with. There must be something, but nothing comes to mind at the moment.
So true Jerry, so true. It's all so sad AND pathetic. Republicans care only about their own selfish desires for power, yet when they have power they don't know what to do with it. Losers....
Obviously I agree with this post's point that a military or government take-over of the gusher shut-down effort would be counter-productive since only the oil companies have the necessary technology. This is something that the general public needs to understand.
But it can't be the case that BP can engage in one safety violation after another that actually kill people, with impunity. If that is currently the case, the laws need to be re-written. This is not the 19th century.
As for the problems that would result if BP were excluded from operating in the US, I'd say they are already causing us even worse problems by being allowed to operate here, and I see no reason to think that their behavior, or its consequences, will become any better in the future. There are other oil companies which could take over the machines and workers which would be left idle by excluding BP from the US -- and taking such a drastic step would put other companies on notice that the days of getting away with egregious abuses are over.
Sue, thanks for this post. Fact is, it is the era of Obama bashing at all costs. There is nothing the man can do right...nothing. It has gotten so fucking ridiculous that my brother and I respond to one another regards whatever..."it's Obama's fault". I am so fucking sick of this right wing bullshit that I truly am ashamed of being an American.
I thought this was a great read and the bold script is mine showcasing the real reason the righties are criticizing the president. It's shameful, and shameful those righties who criticize without looking into the truth of the matter, they just listen and believe the Obama haters who are haters AND liars.
Only one thing.. it is NOT just the right... there are a lot of US Progressives or Liberals doing the same thing.
Look how the media has been on his case... this whole he should show emotion nonsense. Today Tweety even asked Melacon if he wanted the president to shed tears and if that would help any...
Good grief... if he starts jumping up and down and yelling, they will then attack him for being too angry..
I think he has done things just right.. he is involved and on top of things as much as he can be... and as you say, it wouldn't matter what he did.. it would be wrong.
One thing I think Obama could be doing is soliciting ideas from both citizens and other oil execs as to how to clean up and minimize the damage of the gusher. There seems to be alot of people out there with good idea that can't get them through to BP. A task force to field and evaluate these ideas would be a big help, IMO.
I bet if this were a Venezuelan Company or a Chinese company that Holder and Obama wouldn't be so quick to be talking about criminality.
They will only go after an Ally or an American Company and not the dictators.
lisa,
I bet you eat kittens for breakfast.
How's that for just making stuff up? I think it's as good as what you do.
Sue,
I blogged on Palin's arrogant tweets where she mocks Mr. Obama and says he should call her for advise.
I googled an Alaska newspaper that reports her failure to institute a workable risk assessemt agency for Alaska that would deal with these types of disasters.
She's a loud-mouthed fraud.
"Call me, Mr. President," indeed. For what? The laugh of the day?
ADVICE!
Annette I agree and the right keeps harping on MSM being in love with Obama, so stupid! It really doesn't matter if he shits or gets off the pot, they will say something negative about his every move!
LisaG, I keep hearing about James Cameron and his ideas, maybe Obama is listening but not yet talking about it. He is the type who will listen to ALL ideas. Have faith...
I'll be over Shaw. Palin is the biggest Fraud, I don't do the tweet thing but if I did it would infuriate me to no end to read her filthy lies. She is dispicable!
Sue the MSM got him elected. So friggin obvious that even a Harvard graduate would know that.
lisa,
What got Mr. Obama elected was the American people envisioning a half-witted woman one heart-beat away from the presidency. That, and the fact that Obama is light years smarter than McCain and Palin.
Remember, the MSM loved McCain for years and years and always gave the Vietnam POW a pass. But in the last election, he was in over his head, and he was reckless in his choice of a VP.
Those debates were not rigged. We could see for ourselves who had a command of the facts and understood what this country faced. We saw with our own eyes and heard with our own ears what McCain/Palin had to offer, and the country said NO! By 7 percentage points. A larger win than Bush had in his second run for the presidency.
why are the righties so jealous of President Obamas education and what he made of himself? He is smarter than the average bear and they HATE that about him!
They hate everybody smart. They hate anybody that does not agree with them.
Instead of looking for asses to kick his ass should be moving oil booms south.
Obama didn't cause the spill, and nobody expects him to plug the damn hole, but as the Chief Executive, he should be untangling red tape and clearing the bureaucratic hurdles for the relief workers.
The media got him elected .
If they did their job instead of propping up to be same kind of savior or superior being(which he is not)he would have had just as must chance as anyone else being he had "zero" experience.
just shut the hell up lisa. The only people calling Obama a savior were YOUR people, the wacko righties!!
Post a Comment